Mattachioni: Authentic Italian Restaurant in Toronto

About Mattachioni

If you’re searching for an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of Toronto, look no further than Mattachioni. Nestled at 1501 Gerrard St E, this charming Italian restaurant offers a delightful mix of homemade dishes and a warm, unpretentious atmosphere perfect for anything from a casual dinner to a pre-concert meal.

As soon as you step inside, you’re greeted by shelves filled with imported Italian products, wines, cured meats, and artisanal cheeses—an inviting prelude to the gourmet offerings that await you on the menu. The dining room itself buzzes with energy, infused by the ambient sounds of excited conversations mingling with the aroma of freshly baked bread and simmering sauces.

At Mattachioni, every dish is crafted with love and an emphasis on quality ingredients. Among the popular items, the Prosciutto Fresh Mozzarella sandwich stands out. Imagine layers of creamy mozzarella mingling with peppery arugula and savory prosciutto crudo all layered on house-made sourdough for just CA$16.00—each bite is a taste explosion of freshness and flavor.

If you’re in the mood for something to start your meal, try the Rapini, a beautiful sauté of tender greens with garlic and chili flakes, elegantly plated alongside sourdough crostini for just CA$16.00. Or perhaps the Olives with house sourdough at only CA$10.00, perfect for sharing or savouring on your own.

Pizza lovers will rejoice at the array of options here. The Margherita pizza (CA$18.00) is a classic, with its sweet tomato sauce and fresh basil nestled atop creamy mozzarella. Adventurous eaters are encouraged to try the Boccadasse with sweet Genoa salami for CA$22.00, or the Stefano Mistruzzi, offering a lovely combination of Fontina cheese and prosciutto crudo, all for CA$22.00.

Many patrons rave about their experiences at Mattachioni. One happy customer, Lisa Daugherty, shared, “Our server was friendly, and the happy hour specials were fantastic! The vibe was energetic, albeit a bit noisy.” This sentiment is echoed by Dante Alexander, who appreciates the simplistic elegance of the dishes, stating, “The food is simple, but the high-quality ingredients elevate it to a new level.”

While most reviews acclaim the restaurant, there have been minor critiques; for instance, Evan Lee found the pasta sauce lacking in seasoning during a brunch visit. However, the overall sentiment remains positive, as the culinary offerings and atmosphere leave a lasting impression.

In conclusion, Mattachioni is a must-visit for anyone craving delectable, authentic Italian cuisine. Whether you come for a quick snack, a full meal, or simply to browse their amazing selection of Italian products, you’re bound to leave with a full stomach and a smile. Bring your appetite; the delectable experience awaits!

Features

Service options

Outdoor seating

Delivery

Takeaway

Dine-in

Offerings

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

Coffee

Food

Wine

Dining options

Brunch

Lunch

Dinner

Dessert

Seating

Amenities

Bar on site

Payments

Debit cards

NFC mobile payments

Credit cards

Photo Gallery

Location & Map

Guest Reviews

222 Reviews

Lisa Daugherty

29 Oct 2025

Came here for dinner before a concert. The location has a store front as well as dining room. Theres shelves of imported Italian product and a counter where you can buy wines, meats, cheeses etc. The dining room is a bit crowded and close to the store which can made things a bit noisy at times. We came at happy hour, the restaurant had a ton of drink deals and menu specials. Our server was friendly and out food came out quick. My pizza came with a lot more toppings then my friends which was disappointing but other than that we both really enjoyed them.

Jarah C

09 Oct 2025

Highly recommend. Not really sure what the low reviews are as of recent, my experience was fantastic! Similar to when I last got take out there (a few years ago), pizzas are made as ordered and take a normal amount of time to cook so expect to wait 15 or so if ordering take out. Quality and taste is still great as well. It was suggested to try the pizza of the day special, a pesto-based + soppressata. Super delicious !! Almost ate the whole thing myself lol. It was a tad oily though, but the pesto was so fantastic and authentic. The interior is designed as a great family restaurant and I highly recommend coming here!

Carlo Berardinucci

05 Sep 2025

I'm so glad these guys opened up in the East end, I used to drive to Dupont to get their bread. If you want the greatest sourdough bread made in house , this is the place.... KILLER!!! Everything they make here is on another level. I’ve added photos of some of our favourite baked items and how I serve them to my family at home! Focaccia sandwich & their lemon olive oil cake.

Dante Alexander

16 Aug 2025

I’ve been coming here regularly and they never disappoint. The food is simple, but the high quality ingredients elevate it to a new level. Most recently I had lunch here with some friends. We shared the salumi board, which was a great selection of cured meats and pickled vegetables. The trout sandwich was exceptional, their sourdough bread is always a highlight. The pizza has a perfect thin crust and is always cooked just right. I’m not a dessert person but this is the one place I can never resist having a coffee and after meal dessert. The gelato, tiramisu, and especially the cannoli are my personal recommendations. The last time I went the service was a little slow, but this seems to be an exception and not the norm. Usually the service is excellent. They also have a great selection of cocktails and beers.

Evan Lee

11 Aug 2025

I visited this restaurant for brunch. The staff seemed busy and I had to wait for a bit to get my drink, but they were friendly. I really enjoyed the salad, but the pasta and pizza were a little disappointing. While the dough was great, the seasoning was off. The pasta sauce was bland, and some parts of the pizza were too salty. However, the overall vibe of the place is nice.